Comparison of Infill Sampling Criteria
نویسندگان
چکیده
Kriging-based optimization methods are of great interest for aerodynamic design optimization where high-fidelity thus timeconsuming computational fluid dynamics (CFD) are used. In the framework of kriging-based optimization, a core technique called sampling infill criteria (also called adaptive sampling) is used both to search the design space and to refine the surrogate models. Among all the infill criteria, expected improvement (EI) is the favorite one while others are also still in use. However, there is little research compared these criteria when kriging-based optimization method is applied in the aerodynamic design optimization. The following paper addresses this issue by investigating 6 types of infill criteria in the drag minimization problem of the RAE2822 airfoil with different number of design variables. For each infill criterion and each number of design variables, the optimization process is repeated 30 times, and the averaged value and standard deviation are compared. The results show that, some criteria can be comparable to EI or even slight better than EI, while some criteria are much worse.
منابع مشابه
Review of Efficient Surrogate Infill Sampling Criteria with Constraint Handling
This paper discusses the benefits of different infill sampling criteria used in surrogate-model-based constrained global optimization. Here surrogate models are used to approximate both the objective and constraint functions with the assumption that these are computationally expensive to compute. The construction of these surrogates (also known as meta models or response surface models) involve...
متن کاملExploration of Metamodeling Sampling Criteria for Constrained Global Optimization
The use of surrogate models or metamodeling has lead to new areas of research in simulation-based design optimization. Metamodeling approaches have advantages over traditional techniques when dealing with the noisy responses and=or high computational cost characteristic of many computer simulations. This paper focuses on a particular algorithm, Efficient Global Optimization (EGO) that uses krig...
متن کاملEnhancing infill sampling criteria for surrogate-based constrained optimization
Apopular approach to handling constraints in surrogate-based optimization is through the additionof penalty functions to an infill sampling criterion that seeks objective improvement. Typical samplingmetrics, such as expected improvement tend to have multimodal landscapes and can be difficult to search. When the problem is transformed using a penalty approach the search can become riddled with ...
متن کاملEfficient Aerodynamic Optimization Using a Multiobjective Optimization Based Framework to Balance the Exploration and Exploitation
In many aerospace engineering design problems, objective function evaluations can be extremely computationally expensive, such as the optimal design of the aerodynamic shape of an airfoil using high-fidelity computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation. A widely used approach for dealing with expensive optimization is to use cheap global surrogate (approximation) models to substitute expensive...
متن کاملStudy of factors influencing infill development (Case study of Sangelaj neighborhood, urban district 12, Tehran)
Introduction: Considering the challenges of the growing cities, today, the focus is put rather on the development of the existing neighborhoods through infill development. Infill development is indeed a type of development that, in contrast to other urban development policies, is made on the existing urban infrastructure and in the presence of the citizens and neighboring units. Sangelaj neighb...
متن کامل